Volltext-Downloads (blau) und Frontdoor-Views (grau)
  • search hit 1 of 3
Back to Result List

Sentencia del TC polaco de 7 de octubre de 2021 (K 3/21): ¿una cuestión de primacía?

  • This conference speech argues that the judgement of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal K 3/21 can be understood only in the context of the current conflict between the Polish government and the European Union. Moreover, some other details, including how the unconstitutionality of the EU Treaty provisions was formulated, are important. The development of the judicial independence doctrine in the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union may cause discussion. Nonetheless, the judgement K 3/21 is not an example of constructive debate about the division of the competences in the European legal sphere. It constitutes an example of the abuse of the constitutional identity and it resolves a false problem, as in reality there is no conflict between the norms of the Polish Constitution and the EU law as far as the guarantees of the judicial independence are concerned. Moreover, the judgement K 3/21 was delivered by the Constitutional Tribunal which itself lacks the guarantees of independence, what was confirmed by the European Court of Human Rights (7.05.2021 Xero Flor, 4907/18).

Download full text files

Export metadata


Author:Adam Krzywon
Document Type:Public lecture
Year of Completion:2021
Date of first Publication:2021/12/16
Publishing Institution:Deutsches Forschungsinstitut für öffentliche Verwaltung
Contributing Corporation:Universidad Complutense de Madrid / Instituto de Derecho Europeo e Integración Regional
Release Date:2022/01/17
Access Rights:Frei zugänglich
Documents of the German Research Institute for Public Administration (FÖV):Eingeladene Vorträge (wiss. Konferenzen)
Licence (German):License LogoUrheberrechtlich geschützt